Crucifix go-ahead
March 18, 2011
The European Court of Human Rights on Friday ruled that displaying crucifixes in classrooms does not breach the rights of non-Catholic families.
The case was brought to the court by an atheist mother whose two sons attend a public school in the Italian city of Abano Terme. The woman had argued that the refusal to remove the crucifix from classrooms was in violation of the secular principles that public schools are to uphold.
She had, without success, exhausted all levels of jurisdiction within Italy before taking the case to the European Court of Human Rights.
The Vatican on Friday hailed the court's decision as "historic." Robert Zollitsch, head of the German Bishops' Conference, said the court "had taken into account the large part of the Italian population" who - being overwhelmingly catholic - strongly oppose the idea of banning the crucifix from classrooms.
Court overturns earlier decision
The lower chamber of the court ruled in favor of the woman in 2009, saying that displaying crucifixes was in breach of freedom of religion.
The initial verdict caused protests in Catholic circles in Italy and beyond. In a survey at the time, 84 percent of the population spoke out in favor of classroom crucifixes.
The Italian government subsequently refused to accept the 2009 decision and appealed the verdict.
In Friday's ruling, 15 judges of the 17-member ECHR's Grand Chamber ruled in favor of Italy, and two against.
The new verdict is binding on all 47 countries that are members of the Council of Europe, the continent's human rights watchdog.
Author: Andreas Illmer (epd, AFP, dpa)
Editor: Martin Kuebler